Mike 'Boogie' Malin
Gameplay - **
Personality - *****
Diary Room - **
Activeness - ****
All-Star Worthiness - *
Notes - Got evicted way too early. We all know he's a great player
But this was back when he was a rookie and didn't know how to campaign
Alex Coladonato
Gameplay - **
Personality - **
Diary Room - *
Activeness - ****
All-Star Worthiness - N/A
Notes - Didn't really do anything this season. Was instantly a target and left early.
Diane Henry
Gameplay - **
Personality - ***
Diary Room - *
Activeness - **
All-Stars Worthiness - *
Notes - Didn't really come out of her shell personality-wise until the day before her eviction. She seemed like she could have been fun. I was disappointed we didn't see more of her, but her one-liner DRs and inactiveness in the beginning made her boring.
Daniele Donato
Gameplay - **
Personality - ****
Diary Room - **
Activeness - **
All-Star Worthiness - *
Notes - Alyssa just wasn't into this game at all. I know she can be a great player and she can make some really nasty and entertaining DRs. She didn't show off any of that in this game.
Erika Landin
Gameplay - **
Personality - ****
Diary Room - ***
Activeness - ****
All-Stars Worthiness - **
Notes - Was back to his old plan of trying to rely on drama to get into All Stars rather than gameplay. It caught up with him on about Day 2 and he was finally gunned down rather early in the game.
Jun Song
Gameplay - ***
Personality - *****
Diary Room - ****
Activeness - **
All-Star Worthiness - N/A
Notes - Kathleen didn't play as well as she did last time, but she did play a good game. Her problem was being an outcast after Week 1 and not choosing a side. After Ericky's side dwindled, she became a target and eventually left.
Angie Swindell
Gameplay - **
Personality - *
Diary Room - *
Activeness - *
All-Stars Worthiness - *
Notes - Angie pissed me off big time. I had a lot of people who wanted to be intruders, but I let him do it cause he was one of the first to ask. He kept talking like his was interested and very hyped up about it. Then when the twist comes, he goes inactive and doesn't bother doing squat. And when he is evicted, he says in his HG speech that the game didn't interest him and he doesn't return my messages for a HC interview. Is this guy Bree's brother?
Howie Gordon
Gameplay - *
Personality - **
Diary Room - ***
Activeness - ***
All-Stars Worthiness - **
Notes - Howie tried WAY too hard to get into All Stars. His fake acting and personality made me lol. He kinda played like Ricky, using drama rather than gameplay to get into All Stars, something I don't usually respect. He wasn't really strong in competitions and his gameplay was well....different. And I don't mean that in a good way. I'd be interested to see him play as his real self rather than this character he made for Howie if he were to play again.
Richard Bezuidenhout
Gameplay - ***
Personality - ****
Diary Room - ****
Activeness - ****
All-Stars Worthiness - ***
Notes - I think Richard played a very strong game this time around. He still made a lot of stupid mistakes like constantly lying and rejecting deals when he's in danger...but he was the first one to take out someone from the Will/Chelsia/Keesha/Howie alliance and he was really the only one who didn't pretend to be on their side. I actually had him set to be on AS, but he got evicted suddenly pre-jury which hurt any chances of that.
Sheila Kennedy
Gameplay - ***
Personality - ****
Diary Room - ***
Activeness - ***
All-Stars Worthiness - N/A
Notes - Played much better this time around, but played similar to how Kathleen played this time too. She was sort of an outcast. And while she did go against the power alliance, which was in a way a good move since they were plotting on backstabbing her, she once again did it in a public fashion (Ala, attempting to frontdoor James) which I think cost her the game. If she would have been a little bit more sneaky about it and waiting for the right opportunity to pounce, then it would have worked out better.
Sarah Hrejsa
Gameplay - ***
Personality - *****
Diary Room - ****
Activeness - ***
All-Stars Worthiness - N/A
Notes - Played very different this time. She was more upfront and had a lot to say. For some reason, Keesha decided to randomly hate on her which caused her/Will/Keesha/Howie alliance to go after her constantly.
'Crazy' James Zinkland
Gameplay - ***
Personality - **
Diary Room - **
Activeness - ***
All-Stars Worthiness - ***
Notes - He was too honest. He gave away too much information about himself sometimes...which is sometimes good, but in it is what ultimately got him backdoored. Also, some of his moves didn't really make sense to me. I think his secret alliance with Chelsia was great though and those two probably could have gotten further together, but ultimately it didn't happen.
April Lewis
Gameplay - *****
Personality - ****
Diary Room - *****
Activeness - ***
All-Stars Worthiness - ****
Notes - April REALLY surprised me. We all thought she was going to be another Bree in this game, but she ended up really impressing us. She had great DRs, kept us updated constantly. She had a lot of personality which she always didn't show, but was there. She had great gameplan, but it was ruined by stupid moves (Roddy, Nakomis). I think she could have had a chance to win had she had better, smarter allies.
Roddy Mancuso
Gameplay - ***
Personality - **
Diary Room - *
Activeness - *
All-Stars Worthiness - **
Notes - I think Roddy has the potential to be a great player, but he didn't really give all the effort he could have in my opinion. He had some good ideas and his strategy was pretty good. Keesha asking him to quit was absolutely retarded and I agreed 100% with him not trusting her anymore. I liked that he was able to play both sides for awhile up until Will ratted him out. He never wrote in his DR though, so a lot of his gameplay was mysterious. And he made one of the dumbest moves in the game by voting out April over Will.
Keesha Smith
Gameplay - **
Personality - ***
Diary Room - ***
Activeness - *****
All-Stars Worthiness - ***
Notes - Keesha turned me off quite a bit in this game with her constant threatening to DOR, nagging, yelling, insulting, things being unfair, etc. I also think her game probably could have been better socially, since she seemed to just hang around her alliance and make fun of everyone that wasn't in it. She played way, way, way too emotionally. But, she was extremely strong in competitions and won more than anyone in the game. And she had strong allies which helped her get far. She didn't play the best game, but she is defiantly the Dustin of this season.
Jennifer 'Nakomis' Dedmon
Gameplay - **
Personality - ***
Diary Room - **
Activeness - ***
All-Stars Worthiness - **
Notes - She made it a lot further than I expected, but I think she was just the ultimate pawn just because everyone knew they could beat her. She made some really stupid moves in the game and pissed a lot of people off. She had some great allies, but she backstabbed them for....well, really nothing.
Will
Gameplay - ****
Personality - *****
Diary Room - *****
Activeness - *****
All-Stars Worthiness - *****
Notes - Played an extremely strong game, had the perfect allies, evaded bullet after bullet...Nick said in the start that Will has some big expectations to fill with him saying he was going to play like two of the best players in BB history (Danielle and Will), but I think he easily accomplished that. I knew Will was an All Star just a few weeks in and everyone predicted that he would go on to win. I do think he played a poorer end game than in the start. He got way too big of an ego later on and made some pretty stupid moves inbetween. He didn't know how to cover himself up once he started getting exposed. I think because of this he's going to lose. But, he's still an All Star.
Chelsia Hart
Gameplay - *****
Personality - *****
Diary Room - *****
Activeness - *****
All-Stars Worthiness - *****
Notes - Without a doubt the best player this season. She went from nearly being evicted Week 2 thanks to Ericky's big mouth to being in the final two with the second-best player in this game. She made the right the allies, but didn't have to align with everyone in the house to accomplish it. She had her secret deal with James while being in the strong Chelsia/Will/Howie/Keesha alliance. And while that alliance was targeted heavily, people were going after the disliked Keesha and Howie more than they were going after her. She evaded a lot of bullets, won competitions she had to win, and made smart decisions with her voting and targets. I think she has the win clinched 4-3.
